Economic Briefing
Tariff Risk and Relative Impacts
At the time of writing, 25% tariffs on Canada and Mexico were on hold for thirty days pending negotiations and some actions that were going to be taken by both Canada and Mexico in response to Trump Administration demands. China has taken an additional 10% increase in tariffs and has retaliated with a set of specific 15% tariffs on some products and tighter quotas on exports of certain materials used in the US manufacturing sector. Given that conditions are changing so quickly (daily and hourly at times), it does not make sense to try and cover all of the various products that got hit with tariffs.
But on a fundamental basis, there are a couple of conceptual points that are worth considering. First, in the 2018-2019 tariff period, inflation only moved from 1.7% to 1.9% at the time. Granted, conditions were different at the time and the country had not gone through any significant inflationary period in nearly 11 years. Second, the USTR issued more than 18,200 exclusions to tariffs in that period (more than 55,000 were filed for and the rate that exclusions were granted was 35%).
The Trump Administration has also mentioned tariffs that could be imposed on the BRIC nations and the EU, although specifics have not yet been announced (at the time of writing).
In the prior term, tariffs did not change freight volumes in any significant manner. Trade continued between the US and its trading partners abroad. Given that some of the global supply chain was already shifting sourcing will make comparisons difficult (to know what is tariff-induced vs. part of the broader supply chain sourcing diversification trend).
Will US Distribution Patterns Change When Manufacturing Capacity Comes Online?
Over the past five years, manufacturing construction activity is 195.1% higher than it was just prior to the pandemic. This is an average annual growth rate of 24% and even when stripping out the impact of inflation, annual growth in manufacturing construction was still more than 18% annually.
This trend started in earnest just after the 2020 lockdown period. Companies that had been planning to reshore portions of their manufacturing processes accelerated that investment in the 2021-2024 period. But many of those assembly lines are just now starting to come to life and create output. Over the next two years, much of the trillion dollars of reshoring construction activity will start releasing real output. This new volume of products will start to impact local trade lanes and in areas where the volumes are strong enough, could change some of the national distribution volumes.
Under the new Trump Administration, this trend is expected to accelerate in the coming 12-48 months, and many firms will be looking at getting these assembly lines creating output as quickly as possible (especially with the threat of tariffs).
US Manufacturing Rebounds in January, Optimistic Outlook Ahead
Impacting both the transportation sector and manufacturing, the latest Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) from both the Institute for Supply Management and S&P Global showed improvement in January. The S&P Global PMI came in at 51.2, firmly in expansion and much higher than the 49.4 posted in December. New orders were slightly improved, but S&P Global reported that manufacturer optimism was at its highest level in more than five years and the month-over-month change in optimism between December and January was the sharpest in the history of the survey.
ISM reported that its PMI jumped to 50.9, up from 49.2 in December. New orders were sharply higher and both manufacturers and their customers reported that inventories were still “too low”.
That combination of stronger output, fewer backlogs, strong new order books, and solid production capacity likely means that there will be potential for stronger freight volumes in the months to come.
Inside This Edition
Will US Distribution Patterns Change When Manufacturing Capacity Comes Online?
Over the past five years, manufacturing construction activity is 195.1% higher than it was just prior to the pandemic.
US Manufacturing Rebounds in January, Optimistic Outlook Ahead
Impacting both the transportation sector and manufacturing, the latest Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) from both the Institute for Supply Management and S&P Global showed improvement in January.
Load to Truck Ratios Surge in January
Load-to-Truck Ratios (LTR) as reported in the DAT Trendlines data show a national rate of 5.75 (5.75 loads for every available truck).
Intermodal Volumes Start the Year Off Strong
The American Association of Railroads reported that intermodal volumes were trending 10.9% ahead of 2024 volumes through the end of January.
What Are the Impacts of Ending the Red Sea Disruption?
The first 5 US and UK maritime ships started to transit the Red Sea and Suez Canal since early last year.
Transportation Briefing
Load to Truck Ratios Surge in January
Load-to-Truck Ratios (LTR) as reported in the DAT Trendlines data show a national rate of 5.75 (5.75 loads for every available truck). This is the highest level in more than 2 years and earlier in January had touched 9.12 on a national basis. DAT reported that the LTR was 17% higher month-over-month between December and January and was 49.8% higher year-over-year. Obviously, some factors were at work to limit the number of trucks available. Weather conditions displaced significant capacity around the country and the industry is still trying to get rebalanced.
But, at a truckload level, there has been little impact on spot rates. Spot rates were just 0.5% higher between December and January but were unchanged versus January of last year. With the Lunar New Year approaching, slower inbound freight volumes should ease the LTR in the coming weeks.
Intermodal Volumes Start the Year Off Strong
The American Association of Railroads reported that intermodal volumes were trending 10.9% ahead of 2024 volumes through the end of January. This continued a strong pace set in all of 2024 of 9.5% for the full year. What is not yet clear is how much of this is still a combination of factors that “pulled forward” volumes as purchasing managers tried to get ahead of what they perceived late last year as a significant east and gulf coast port strike. And there are fears that tariffs and trade quota retaliation (a trade war) could be a factor that would make inbounding freight volumes early plausible. This could be part of the rationale for stronger intermodal volumes thus far this year.
There is little evidence that this early inbound strategy is overstocking business inventories (leading to lighter freight volumes later in Q1 and throughout Q2). In most cases, anecdotes suggest that many purchasing managers were inbounding products that have been historically difficult to get at times, and those items that could create bottlenecks or disruptions in assembly lines and manufacturing output.
In any event, this stronger intermodal volume was also showing up in Canadian rail traffic (up 11.5%), and Mexico traffic (which was up 25.1%). There was no difference in the number of working days year-over-year.
What Are the Impacts of Ending the Red Sea Disruption?
The first 5 US and UK maritime ships started to transit the Red Sea and Suez Canal since early last year. For review, Houthi Rebels in Yemen were targeting commercial maritime vessels in a key chokepoint at the mouth to the Red Sea. With more than 130 strikes between October 2023 and July 2024 with 77 ships taking damage and 3 being lost, insurance firms and carriers decided to avoid the region. That added more than 11 days of transit to those shipments affected (estimated to be 10-15% of global shipments that use the Suez Canal), added a geopolitical premium of $6 to the average price of oil, and pushed maritime rates up by nearly 200% in many trade lanes in the third quarter of 2024.
As mentioned, the situation can change quickly. With a cease-fire agreement between Israel and Hamas, the Houthi Rebels in Yemen have agreed to not target any vessel that is not an Israeli ship. Confusion can still be a risk, and some carriers have said that they will not yet transit the Red Sea, but some will be bold and make the transit (heating up competitive pressures on others). Reversing the impacts of a surge in shipping costs and oil prices may take longer, but competitive pressures may build much more quickly for some carriers.